Winter Sowing Flowers in Milk Jugs: Method and Calendar - Homegrown Garden

30-DAY SATISFACTION GUARANTEE

Winter Sowing Flowers: The Milk Jug Method and a Sowing Calendar by Last Frost Date

Taped milk jugs with their caps off sitting in a crate on fresh snow, set out for winter sowing

Winter sowing means starting seeds outdoors in the middle of winter, inside a vented container that works like a tiny greenhouse. A gallon milk jug is the classic choice. You cut it open, fill the bottom with moist potting mix, sow, tape it shut with the cap off, and set it out in the snow. The seeds get the cold, damp spell many perennials need before they sprout, then come up in spring on their own schedule, already used to wind and sun. Trudi Davidoff introduced the method on GardenWeb in 2000, and extension Master Gardeners from Maryland to Washington State teach it now.

Where most guides go vague is timing. "December to March" means one thing in Minnesota and another in Georgia. So along with the full jug method, you get a sowing calendar keyed to your own last spring frost date, a decoder for seed packet wording, and our flower seeds sorted into the jugs they belong in.

Winter Sowing at a Glance

Step What to do Source
Container A translucent milk jug, or any container with a clear or milky top, cap off Illinois Extension, Cornell Cooperative Extension
Drainage 4 to 6 holes in the bottom, spread out rather than one in the center University of Maryland Extension, WSU Extension
Mix 3 to 4 inches of moist potting mix, at least 4 inches for perennials and natives University of Maryland Extension
Timing Cold-needing perennials first, hardy annuals next, tender annuals last (calendar below) Penn State, Maryland, and Illinois Extension
Placement Outdoors in winter sun, open to rain and snow, out of strong wind Penn State Extension, Illinois Extension
Venting Once seedlings are up, open the top on sunny days and close it at dusk Illinois Extension, Ohio State Extension
Transplanting After seedlings have at least two true leaves University of Maryland Extension

How to Set Up a Milk Jug for Winter Sowing

  1. Wash it. Hot, soapy water and a good rinse. Gallon jugs are standard, but University of Maryland Extension (UMD) Master Gardeners also use 2-liter bottles, food tubs, and deli containers.
  2. Make drainage holes. UMD calls for 4 to 6 holes in the bottom, made with a drill, knife, or soldering iron. Spread them out: a Skagit County Master Gardener writing for WSU Extension found one center hole did not drain well in a wet Pacific Northwest winter.
  3. Cut the hinge. Cut around the jug about 4 inches up from the bottom and stop short under the handle, so the top flips open but stays attached.
  4. Label it. Plant name and date. The WSU writer labels each jug in three places (bottom, top, and a tag in the soil) because household markers fade after months outside. Trust the tag inside the jug most.
  5. Add moist mix. More on this below. A coffee filter in the bottom keeps the mix in and slugs out.
  6. Sow one kind of seed per jug.
  7. Tape it shut and leave the cap off. Run duct tape all the way around the seam. Penn State Extension suggests light-colored duct tape, and Ohio State's Licking County Master Gardeners warn against masking tape.
  8. Set it outside in winter sun, never on a covered porch (Penn State), since snow and rain do much of the watering, and out of strong wind (Illinois). A milk crate keeps jugs upright in a windy yard. UMD suggests part sun and WSU a southeast spot; in a mild, sunny winter we would lean toward part sun. Keep jugs away from pets and small children.

Translucent or Clear?

Light has to get in. Illinois Extension says milk jugs "that allow light to penetrate work well," and a Cornell Cooperative Extension guide from St. Lawrence County says the top must be clear or translucent. The argument is over clear versus milky. Jami Boys of An Oregon Cottage switched to milk jugs after a clear clamshell "burnt the new starts with even a small amount of sun." The WSU guide, on the other hand, happily uses clear rotisserie chicken domes alongside jugs and widens the vent holes as plants grow.

Our take: milky jugs are the safer default in mild, sunny winters, and clear containers are fine if you vent them more. If you cannot see your hand moving behind the plastic, the container is too dark.

Cap On or Cap Off?

The extension guides say off. Penn State says to leave the top open, UMD writes "do not put caps on jugs," and Cornell's Orleans County guide removes the cap too. The open spout lets rain and snow in and hot air out.

Niki Jabbour of Savvy Gardening goes the other way. She often leaves the cap on until the seeds germinate, then takes it off for airflow. The case for that is moisture, since a capped jug dries out more slowly in a dry, windy winter. If you try it, check the mix during warm spells and pull the cap the day you see green.

Best Soil for Winter Sowing

Not garden soil, topsoil, or straight compost. The Cornell St. Lawrence guide says they drain poorly, which can rot seeds and encourage damping off, and Penn State adds that garden soil can carry pathogens and weed seeds.

Past that, the guides split. Penn State uses 2 to 4 inches of soilless seed-starting mix. The Cornell St. Lawrence writer points out that seed-starting mix has no nutrients, so seedlings must move out young, while potting mix feeds them long enough to stay in the jug a while. In a wet climate, skip mixes with moisture-control crystals; the WSU writer traced green algae on the soil to excess moisture. Ohio State's guide says not to add fertilizer.

Our pick is a plain potting mix, 4 inches deep. UMD sets 4 inches as the minimum for perennials and natives, and slow growers like lavender and milkweed may sit in the jug for weeks after they sprout. Wet it until water runs out the bottom, then let it drain to what Illinois Extension calls "a damp sponge."

Sowing: How Many Seeds and How Deep

An open milk jug with moist potting mix, seeds on the surface, and a plant tag inside, next to duct tape and a marker

Ohio State's guide, drawing on gardener Kevin Lee Jacobs, sows tiny seeds thinly (you will cut them apart later), 6 to 8 medium seeds per gallon jug, and only 4 to 6 large ones so the seedlings do not shade each other. UMD mixes very fine seed with coarse sand or vermiculite so it scatters evenly.

For depth, follow the packet and leave light-loving seed on top. Iowa State University Extension's germination table lists snapdragon as needing light, bachelor's button as "lightly cover," and zinnia, cosmos, and sunflower as needing darkness. Johnny's Selected Seeds says to surface-sow Iceland poppies when direct seeding. Press every seed into the mix, and for snapdragons, Johnny's notes that a fine layer of vermiculite holds moisture and discourages algae without blocking light.

When to Winter Sow: A Calendar by Last Frost Date

Extension timing comes in months. Penn State sows perennials and hardy annuals from December to March and tender plants in March or April; UMD sows cold-needing natives and perennials December through February and cosmos and zinnia in March and April. Those windows fit the states they were written for and slide by weeks everywhere else, so we turned them into weeks before your last spring frost, in three groups:

  • Group 1, cold first: perennials and natives whose seed needs a cold, moist spell before it sprouts. Sow from the winter solstice until 10 weeks before your last frost, the earlier the better. University of Maryland Extension's native seed guide starts this group as early as late November.
  • Group 2, hardy annuals: flowers that, in Illinois Extension's words, "tolerate cold soil, cool air and light frosts." Sow from 14 to 6 weeks before your last frost.
  • Group 3, tender annuals: flowers that need warm soil and die at the first frost. Sow from 6 to 2 weeks before your last frost.

Hardy annual seedlings (Group 2) can go into the garden about 4 weeks before your last frost, the timing Illinois Extension gives for hardy annuals. Groups 1 and 3 wait for the frost date: Cornell's Orleans County guide divides and plants out its jugs once frost danger has passed.

Your last spring frost Roughly zone Group 1: cold first Group 2: hardy annuals Group 3: tender annuals Plant out Group 2 Plant out Groups 1 and 3
Late May to early June 3 to 4 late Dec to late Mar late Feb to mid Apr mid Apr to mid May from early May from early Jun
Mid-May 4 to 5 late Dec to early Mar early Feb to early Apr early Apr to early May from mid Apr from mid May
Early May 5 to 6 late Dec to mid Feb late Jan to mid Mar mid Mar to mid Apr from early Apr from early May
Mid-April 6 to 7 late Dec to early Feb early Jan to early Mar early Mar to early Apr from mid Mar from mid Apr
Early April 7 late Dec to late Jan late Dec to mid Feb mid Feb to mid Mar from early Mar from early Apr
Mid-March 8 late Dec to early Jan (fridge first, see below) late Dec to early Feb early Feb to early Mar from mid Feb from mid Mar

"Early" means the 1st to the 10th, "mid" the 11th to the 20th, and "late" the 21st on. Treat the zone column as a loose hint. The USDA hardiness map is based on average winter lows, not frost dates, and the zone-to-frost tables published online disagree by weeks. Look up your own last frost date by zip code or ask your county extension office, then read across that row.

Timeline chart of winter sowing windows for cold-needing perennials, hardy annuals, and tender annuals at six last frost dates

A worked example: say your last frost is April 20. Group 1 jugs go out from December 21 to about February 9, hardy annuals from January 12 to March 9, and tender annuals from March 9 to April 6. Hardy annual seedlings can go into beds from about March 23, perennials and tender annuals from April 20.

The Group 1 cutoff is early on purpose. A Cornell Cooperative Extension writer in zone 4 warned in mid-March that seeds needing more than 30 days of cold might already be too late, and mid-March in zone 4 is roughly 9 to 10 weeks before last frost. If you plant a fall garden too, our fall garden planting calendar by zone works the same way, counting back from the first fall frost.

Read the Seed Packet

Packet wording tells you the group. This decoder uses the phrases Ohio State's Licking County Master Gardeners tell winter sowers to look for:

If the packet says Put it in
"Requires cold stratification" or "a period of cold dormancy" Group 1
"Hardy annual" or "sow in place in fall or winter" Group 2
"Sow 4 to 6 weeks before average last frost" Group 2
"Start indoors 4 to 6 weeks before last frost" Late in Group 2
"Direct sow after danger of frost has passed" Group 3
"Requires light to germinate" or "surface sow" Any group, but do not cover the seed

Mild Winters: Zone 8 and Warmer

Winter sowing assumes a real winter; the Cornell St. Lawrence guide notes it is most popular in zones 4 to 8. In our mid-March row the Group 1 window shrinks to about two weeks, too little cold for milkweed, so in zone 8 and warmer we would give cold-needing seed its chill in the refrigerator first (see how to stratify seeds), then sow. Hardy annuals have it easier: NC State Extension says bachelor's buttons can be seeded straight into the garden in fall where winters are mild, and Johnny's lists fall and winter direct sowing for Iceland poppies.

What If Seeds Sprout During a Thaw?

Here the guides disagree. Illinois Extension waits until January or February to start, because seeds can sprout in a warm spell and then die in the cold that follows. Ohio State's guide says early sprouting "is not a problem for perennials and hardy annuals." Both are right, about different seeds. Hardy seedlings shrug off a cold snap and tender ones do not, which is why Group 3 waits and nothing on our calendar starts before the solstice.

Which of Our Flower Seeds Go in Which Jug

This is how we sort eight flowers from our own catalog. Treat it as a starting point, not the full list of flowers for winter sowing.

HOME GROWN Bachelor's Button seed pack on a wooden garden bench in front of blue cornflower blooms

Flower Group What to know
Common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) 1 Our pack recommends 30 days of cold, so sow it first. Slow to come up. Spreads by rhizomes, so give it room.
English lavender 'Munstead' (Lavandula angustifolia) 1 UMD lists lavender among the perennials to sow December through February. Slow from seed, so pot it up before it goes in the ground.
Bachelor's button (Centaurea cyanus) 2 A hardy annual per Illinois Extension. Cover lightly.
Iceland poppy (Papaver nudicaule) 2 Surface-sow. Johnny's says it grows best below 70°F. Move it as an unbroken clump.
Tetra snapdragon (Antirrhinum majus) 2 A hardy annual per Illinois Extension. Needs light to germinate, so leave the seed on the surface.
Fairy snapdragon (Linaria maroccana) 2 A Moroccan toadflax, not a true snapdragon. Select Seeds lists it as a hardy annual, and NC State notes it stops blooming in summer heat.
Johnny jump up 'Helen Mount' (Viola tricolor) 2 The parent of modern pansies, which UMD lists among the hardy annuals to winter sow.
Foxglove (Digitalis purpurea) 2 A biennial: leaves the first year, flower spikes the second. Highly toxic (see below).

About those snapdragon names: our Fairy and Spurred snapdragon packs are Linaria maroccana, also called Moroccan toadflax, with small snapdragon-like flowers. True snapdragons are Antirrhinum majus, like our Tetra pack. Both go in Group 2.

HOME GROWN Tetra Snapdragon seed pack in front of tall pink, yellow, and orange snapdragon spikes

Hold these for Group 3: zinnia, cosmos, and marigold. UMD and WSU both put cosmos and zinnia in March or April. We skip the jug for sunflowers: Iowa State notes they do not transplant well, so we sow them straight into the garden after frost.

Two safety notes. NC State Extension rates common milkweed as low severity, but every part of the plant is poisonous if eaten, a problem for cats, dogs, and horses, and its milky sap can irritate skin and eyes. Foxglove is rated high severity: its flowers, leaves, roots, and stems contain cardiac glycosides. Wear gloves for milkweed and keep both jugs out of reach of pets and children. Plan milkweed's spot with care too. The Missouri Botanical Garden says it "can spread somewhat rapidly by rhizomes and may be aggressive for smaller garden areas."

Watering and Venting Winter-Sown Jugs

Through winter, let snow and rain do the watering, and leave the jugs be even when temperatures drop, as long as nothing has sprouted (Cornell St. Lawrence). Check about once a week. Condensation inside the jug means the mix is moist. No condensation and dry-looking mix means it needs water: sprinkle gently through the top, or stand the jug in 2 to 3 inches of water overnight, which Ohio State's guide does only when it is above freezing.

Once seedlings appear, a closed jug can overheat fast on a sunny day:

  • Open the tops on sunny days and close them at dusk (Illinois Extension, Ohio State).
  • In a warm spell after germination, open the jugs and move them to shade. UMD warns that direct sun and heat can harm tiny seedlings.
  • If a hard freeze is forecast after germination, cover the jugs with a sheet, blanket, or row cover (UMD). This matters most for Group 3.
  • When evening temperatures stay above freezing, Garden Gate magazine says you can leave the tops open for good.

Transplanting Winter-Sown Seedlings

Hands lifting a square block of winter-sown seedlings out of a milk jug to plant in a garden bed

Seedlings are ready once they have at least two true leaves (UMD, Ohio State); the calendar above gives your plant-out dates. Penn State says jug-grown seedlings do not need hardening off, since they grew up outdoors. UMD still opens the containers fully for 2 to 3 days before transplanting, and we would too.

Slide the whole block of mix out of the jug. The brownie method cuts it into squares with a sharp knife, each planted as a clump, and it is the only practical way with thickly sown fine seed. The taffy method, as the WSU writer describes it, gently pulls apart 2 or 3 seedlings at a time. UMD warns the roots are fragile, though Ohio State's guide says outdoor-grown seedlings take severed roots better than you would expect.

Two exceptions. Poppies get the brownie method, early and in one piece, because Select Seeds warns that "poppies dislike being disturbed." Slow perennials like lavender and milkweed can go into 4-inch pots first, as the WSU guide suggests, and into the garden once they have some size. Our guides to transplanting seedlings and growing lavender from seed pick up from there.

Winter Sowing Troubleshooting

Problem Likely cause What to do
Nothing up by May Some seeds take months. The WSU guide names columbine and milkweed as late germinators. Keep the jug moist and leave it out into summer before giving up.
Green film on the mix Algae from excess moisture (WSU) Add drainage holes, and next time use a mix without moisture-control additives.
Seedlings wilted or scorched on a sunny day Heat trapped in a closed jug Open the top on sunny days; move jugs to shade in a warm spell (UMD).
No condensation, mix pulling from the sides A dry, windy spell or a spot sheltered from snow Water from the top, or soak from the bottom on a day above freezing (Ohio State).
Jugs blown over Wind Group them in a milk crate (Penn State).
Tender seedlings came up and froze Group 3 seed sown too early Resow in the Group 3 window for your frost date.
A solid mat of seedlings Sown too thickly Transplant in brownie blocks and thin as they grow. Next time, 6 to 8 medium seeds per jug (Ohio State).

Winter Sowing Questions

Is it too late to winter sow?

Usually not. Tender annuals go in last, March or April by Penn State's timing. The exception is Group 1 seed that needs a long cold spell: within about 10 weeks of your last frost, give it its cold in the refrigerator first, then sow.

Can you winter sow in zone 3?

Yes. Cold winters suit the method, and the Cornell writer in zone 4 sows from January through early April. Use the late May to early June row of the calendar, and expect slow perennials to take until late spring to show.

Can I use plastic totes or other containers instead of milk jugs?

Yes, if the container lets light through, drains, vents, and holds enough mix. UMD uses 2-liter bottles, food tubs, deli containers, and plastic drink cups, with at least 4 inches of mix for perennials. For anything with a lid, the WSU guide cuts vent holes in the lid and widens them as the plants grow.

Can you winter sow tomatoes?

Yes, but last. UMD sows tomatoes in April, and Cornell's Orleans County guide puts them in the jugs last because they need warm soil to germinate and can rot if they sit in moist mix too long.


Sources: Penn State Extension, Starting Seeds in Winter (Lori Voll-Wallace, updated 2025); University of Maryland Extension, All the Dirt on Winter Sowing (Charles County Master Gardeners) and Collecting and Sowing Native Plant Seed (2025); University of Illinois Extension, Winter Seed Sowing (Nicole Flowers-Kimmerle, 2019) and Annuals; Ohio State University Extension, Licking County Master Gardener Volunteers, Winter Seed Sowing; WSU Skagit County Extension Master Gardeners, Jump Start Your 2023 Garden with Winter Sowing (Kelly Maupin, 2022); Cornell Cooperative Extension, Winter Sowing 101 (Orleans County, 2025) and Start Seeds Outdoors Now with Winter Sowing! (St. Lawrence County, 2022); NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (common milkweed, foxglove, cornflower, toadflax, wild pansy); Iowa State University Extension, Germination Requirements for Annuals and Vegetables; Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Asclepias syriaca; USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map; Johnny's Selected Seeds growing guides for Iceland poppy and snapdragon; Select Seeds; Savvy Gardening (Niki Jabbour, updated 2025); Garden Gate (2024); An Oregon Cottage (Jami Boys, 2024).

Ready to fill a few jugs? Our Bachelor Button 6,000-seed pack is a hardy annual for the middle of the calendar, with enough seed for a whole crate of jugs. Or browse all of our flower seeds and sort them with the packet decoder above.

Search